Investing in Holmdel Real Estate: Is Now the Right Time?

Investing in Holmdel Real Estate: Is Now the Right Time?


Holmdel, NJ, is a town where suburban tranquility merges with the vibrancy of opportunity, making it ideal for those seeking a balanced lifestyle. Just a convenient commute from the fast-paced energy of New York City, Holmdel offers residents the best of both worlds—a peaceful retreat to return to each day without sacrificing easy access to urban amenities.

The town's appeal extends beyond its strategic location; Holmdel is a community enriched with expansive green spaces and scenic landscapes that invite outdoor enthusiasts and families to explore and unwind. Holmdel Park, a local favorite, provides a picturesque backdrop for everything from morning jogs to afternoon picnics, while the nearby beaches offer a perfect weekend escape. Holmdel's real estate market reflects its enduring appeal, offering a smart investment opportunity for those looking to buy, sell, or hold property in this thriving community.

Holmdel's robust market

Holmdel's real estate market continues demonstrating its strength and appeal, particularly in July 2024, when the median sold price reached $890,000, translating to $341 per square foot. This marks a 3.2% increase from the previous year, underscoring the steady appreciation of property values in the area. Such a rise in home prices reflects the town's desirability and the confidence buyers have in Holmdel as a worthwhile investment.

To put Holmdel's market into perspective, the median home price across the United States was $420,800 during the first quarter of 2024, while New Jersey's state median was $485,900. Holmdel's higher median price indicates the town's unique status as a premium location, offering peace, convenience, and lifestyle amenities.

Moreover, the competitive nature of Holmdel's market is evident in the sales figures for July 2024, where 63% of homes sold over the asking price. The statistic highlights the demand and limited supply driving prices upward. On the other hand, 33% of homes sold below the asking price, suggesting that while the market is competitive, savvy buyers still have opportunities to negotiate.

Exploring nearby markets

Holmdel's neighboring towns of Marlboro, Colts Neck, and Middletown are also experiencing dynamic real estate markets, each offering unique appeal. In July 2024, Marlboro saw its median sold price rise to $760,000, reflecting an impressive 8.7% increase from the previous year. The market in Marlboro is notably fast-paced, with 81% of homes selling in under 30 days and 69% of these transactions closing above the asking price. 

Colts Neck, known for its sprawling estates and upscale living, continues to lead the region with a median sold price of $1,250,000 in July 2024. The modest price increase of 1.2% from last year underscores the stability of this high-end market. Like Marlboro, the market here is quick-moving, with 83% of homes selling within 30 days and 67% of sales exceeding the asking price.

Middletown recorded a median sold price of $642,000 in July 2024, an 11.7% increase from the previous year. Middletown's market is particularly competitive, with 90% of homes selling in less than 30 days and 77% of these properties fetching prices above the asking price. The rapid turnover and price growth highlight Middletown's increasing popularity, making it a hot spot for real estate activity. These nearby areas reflect the overall strength and appeal of the region's real estate market.

Housing supply in Holmdel

The housing supply in Holmdel has shown notable activity over the past few months, reflecting a dynamic and evolving market. In June 2024, 80 homes were available for sale, slightly increasing to 83 in July 2024. Despite this modest rise in inventory, the number of homes sold saw a significant jump — from 13 in June to 27 in July. The surge in sales demonstrates the strong demand for homes in Holmdel, where buyers are eager to secure properties despite the limited supply.

Interestingly, while the number of homes sold increased, the average time on the market also changed. In June 2024, homes in Holmdel spent an average of 17 days on the market before being sold. By July, this average had extended to 33 days. The increase in time on the market could indicate a slight shift in buyer behavior, perhaps reflecting a more competitive market where buyers take longer to finalize decisions. However, most homes  — 81% of those sold — still moved quickly, selling in under 30 days, which underscores the continued high demand and the swift pace of transactions in Holmdel.

Overall, the current housing supply in Holmdel remains tight, with homes selling relatively quickly despite the slight increase in market time. This makes it an area where both buyers and sellers need to act decisively.

Holmdel's investment potential

The town presents a compelling opportunity for those considering Holmdel as a location for investment properties. As of the latest data, the average rent for a two-bedroom home in Holmdel is $2,805. While this reflects a 13% decrease from the previous year, it still positions Holmdel as a competitive market within the region. Reducing rental rates could attract a broader range of tenants, making it easier for landlords to maintain occupancy.

Comparatively, the average rent in nearby Marlboro is slightly higher at $2,927, while North Middleton's average rent is $2,695. These figures highlight Holmdel's position within a competitive rental landscape, offering a balance between affordability for tenants and profitability for landlords.

Approximately 10% of homes in Holmdel are rental properties, indicating a small but important base of rental demand. This suggests a healthy balance, where rental properties are in demand without saturating the market. For potential landlords, this means that while competition exists, there is also a steady stream of renters seeking homes in this tranquil suburban setting.

Timing the market

As potential investors weigh their options, Holmdel's current real estate landscape suggests that now could be an opportune time to make a move. One of the most compelling factors is the recent decline in mortgage rates, which have dropped by a percentage point. According to Freddie Mac, these rates may continue to trend downward, potentially reaching the 6% range. Lower mortgage rates make it more affordable for buyers to finance their investments and increase the potential for higher returns on those investments.

Another key consideration is the long-term appreciation of home values. Historically, national trends show that home values have been on a consistent upward trajectory since 1965, typically doubling in value every ten years until 2000. While the pace of appreciation slowed somewhat, the overall trend remains positive. The long-term growth pattern indicates that real estate remains a reliable investment, particularly in areas like Holmdel, where demand remains strong.

The current market conditions present a favorable environment for both buyers and sellers.

Buyers can benefit from lower mortgage rates and the potential for continued home value appreciation, making it an ideal time to invest in properties that are likely to increase in value over time. Sellers can capitalize on the sustained demand and rising property values to secure strong returns on their investments. All signs point to Holmdel being a market worth entering or expanding in, whether you're a seasoned investor or starting.

Partnering for success

The Gerine Team offers progressive solutions tailored to each client's unique needs. Their expertise ensures that you get the best price for your property and maximize your investment potential, regardless of market conditions. By leveraging their in-depth market knowledge and innovative strategies, The Gerine Team delivers exceptional results, making them the ideal choice for anyone looking to buy or sell real estate in Holmdel.



Work With Us

To provide superior quality real estate services that customers recommend to family and friends, and we are proud of.

Follow Me on Instagram